Startup Marketing Agencies vs Traditional Agencies

Marketing agencies are experts who manage ad campaigns and marketing strategies that help brands increase sales, brand awareness and ROI. They could be traditional agencies or startup marketing agencies. Each one is suited to different kinds of projects, budgets, and clients.

Traditional marketing agencies are more suited to larger clients with big campaign budgets. In contrast, startup digital marketing agencies are more flexible in pricing, working with low budgets and building brands from scratch. They are adept at helping startups grow their brands and market new products on limited budgets, going beyond conventional marketing playbooks.

In this article, we’ll walk you through on the key areas to consider when evaluating marketing agencies for your startup:

How is marketing different for a startup
Key differences between startup digital marketing agencies and traditional agencies
Common startup marketing challenges
Benefits of startup digital marketing agencies over traditional agencies
How to pick the right digital marketing agency as a startup founder

Is marketing different for a startup?

Marketing for startups differs because startups have limited resources. For instance, a startup with a product at the introduction or beta-testing stage will need to sign first users as paid customers. So, they are targeting a different kind of customer compared to established businesses.

While established brands already have loyal consumers and evangelists, new brands need to work harder on customer acquisition and brand recognition. According to CB Insights, 38% of startups fail because of financial constraints.

So, the challenge for most startups is to succeed in spite of evident constraints. Hence, they need to use a lean approach and focus on strategies that are easy to test, monitor, and scale, and startup marketing agencies are more suited to these situations than traditional marketing agencies.

Startup digital marketing agencies vs. traditional agencies: Key differences

The table provided below contrasts and compares digital and traditional marketing agencies to highlight the distinct characteristics of each:

Comparison	Digital marketing agencies	Traditional marketing agencies
Agility	More adaptable to market changes and audience feedback due to having smaller teams and direct contact with the clients.	They are less flexible and slower to adjust to changing conditions and tech technology because they follow a standardized procedure.
Cost efficiency	Often cheaper and have more flexible payment terms, including hourly, monthly, per-project, and performance-based payment models.	Often more expensive due to higher upfront costs, retainers, and long-term contract lock-in requirements.
Scalability	Scale faster and more easily. They understand how to adjust campaigns to fit the growth of a startup without major changes in strategy or budget.	They require more time and money to scale marketing operations. Adapting campaigns involves more complex and slower processes.
Feedback loop	You are likely to have direct contact with the team member handling your account. Hence, you get instant feedback.	Feedback is often delayed and not direct due to complex organizational structure and multiple layers of communication.
Startup domain experience	Most strategists at startup digital marketing agencies have either worked with or for startups. So, they have a better understanding of the unique marketing challenges faced by startups and how to win while being lean.	Traditional agencies may not fully grasp the realities of startup marketing because they are used to working with larger organizations in more settled settings.
Experience with low-budgets	Founders want speed and results at the lowest cost possible. Startup marketing agencies understand and create solutions around this.	They are used to working with large firms that have big budgets to invest in marketing. They are unsuitable for startups with financial constraints.
Workflow structure	Startups have more automation. For instance, Kaya uses automated dashboards, reporting processes, and a task board to keep everyone in the loop.	Their processes are more standardized. They prefer office meetings and physical presentations, and this may not suit startups that need to move fast.

Common startup marketing challenges

Startups are unique in every aspect compared to conventional businesses. They face common challenges when devising effective marketing plans. Here are some of these challenges:

Budget constraints and resource allocation

Startups are mostly cash-strapped and must prioritize marketing resource allocation. Hiring a marketing team, buying the relevant software and funding campaigns can prove expensive. Startups cannot afford to splurge, especially considering they need to test and iterate a lot.

Lack of marketing expertise

Most founders with technical backgrounds lack the marketing expertise required to achieve and sustain results. Hence, it is risky to engage in marketing campaigns under such conditions. Marketing expertise is needed to understand a brand's ideal customers, what channels to find them, and how to reach them without depleting a limited budget.

Hard to find and connect with ideal customers

Finding product-market fit can be a long journey, even harder if you’re building a niche product. While many founders build great products, they find it difficult to find the early adopters, let alone communicate the unique value proposition effectively to the ideal customers. So, they spend time targeting the wrong customer profiles, optimizing for the wrong keywords or creating ad copies that do not highlight the product’s benefits.

Hiring takes time and money: Fractional CMO vs. in-house marketing vs. marketing agency

Selecting the right option between hiring a fractional CMO or in-house marketing vs. outsourcing to a startup marketing agency can be complicated.

In-house marketing team: The average time to hire is around six weeks, and the average salary for a marketing specialist in the US is US$79,149. New hires may also need training, and there is always a risk of hiring the wrong fit.
Fractional CMO: Hiring a fractional CMO costs startups around US$150 to US$200 per hour. Although slightly cheaper than having a team, fractional CMOs are not suitable for the long term.
Startup marketing agency: A startup digital marketing agency is a cost-effective alternative to hiring fractional CMOs or setting up an in-house marketing team. It is time-saving, offers knowledge transfer, supports lean marketing methods, and allows startups to focus on other essential business activities.

Building strong partnerships

A startup in its early stages may struggle to get the personalized attention it needs from a traditional marketing agency. Also, since they do not have established products, it becomes harder to build partnerships that could improve their brand.

Scaling marketing effort

As your startup grows, you need to increase your marketing efforts. However, having an in-house team is costly and time-consuming. Scaling marketing efforts or ad campaigns also requires a different approach, which is something many founders struggle with.

Benefits of startup digital marketing agencies over traditional agencies

Startup marketing agencies are not a silver bullet for all marketing challenges. However, they provide flexible solutions that help you navigate the complex startup ecosystem. Here are other benefits of choosing startup marketing agencies over traditional marketing agencies.

Scalability and flexibility

You may succeed with your first ad campaign, but there isn’t enough data to recognize the strategy or build on any pattern. A startup marketing agency has the experience to understand ad campaign data and recognize patterns that can be developed into a strategy. They are also able to quickly respond to changes in industry trends and ad platform algorithms.

Data-driven decisions

A HubSpot 2023 survey states that 36% of marketers identified data as essential for understanding and reaching target audiences. Startup marketing agencies understand that you don’t have to embark on a strategy just because you can. Rather, you allow the data to guide you. They focus on what works, experiment, and make improvements backed by current data.

Cost-effective solutions

Startup marketing agencies understand how to use strategies that will quickly deliver the most success at the lowest possible cost. They can also help you reach your target without heavy investments. They invest in new technology that ensures they can automate marketing tasks, which saves time and cost.

Wide reach

This is not to say that traditional agencies do not have a broad reach. They do. However, startup digital marketing agencies focus on community building and relationships that are better suited to startups. For instance, some are YC-backed, and some have partnerships with Meta and Google. Founders enjoy the benefits of these partnerships when they work with a startup marketing agency.

Strong partnerships

Unlike larger agencies, startup marketing agencies often provide a more dedicated client experience due to a flatter hierarchy. Traditional agencies are known to prioritize larger accounts and rely on conventional marketing playbooks but these are typically unsuitable for startups. As a startup founder or leading a lean team in one, you are also more likely to establish a stronger, direct personal relationship with your account manager at a startup marketing agency.

Cultural fit

Experts at startup digital marketing agencies have either previously worked at startups or have handled many projects for startups. They understand the challenges of typical startups and the value of testing and iteration, and that is reflected in their approach. They know that regular go-to-market strategies may not work for startups, so they are more willing to create customized solutions.

How to pick the right digital marketing agency as a startup founder

Choosing the right digital marketing agency is essential to startup marketing success. Here are key considerations to ensure you pick the best agency for your needs:

Technical expertise

You want to find a startup marketing agency that is in tune with your most effective ad platforms and tech stack. They must also show domain knowledge at the product or industry level, channel expertise, and growth for startups at different stages.

Cultural compatibility and team synergy

You want to ensure that the startup digital marketing agencies are fast, data-driven, and lean. Ask about their technology stack and ensure it aligns with your expectations. Also, verify their approach to testing and how they incorporate technology and automation in their processes.

An ideal digital marketing agency should operate as an extension of your team, sharing their knowledge and offering practical solutions that help fast-track your growth.

Transparency

Choose an agency that is open and clear about its pricing, processes, and results delivery. Ideally, they should present cost estimates with breakdowns. They should also allow you to view task boards and other documents to help monitor the progress of the project.

Clear goals and strategy

The agency must understand your business goals and be able to translate these into actionable marketing strategies. This includes developing realistic short, medium, and long-term recommendations with timelines.

A reliable digital marketing agency will have a clear, easy-to-understand strategy for each marketing campaign, ad channel, or experiment. They should be able to explain to you how they will implement strategies to help you find qualified leads, increase traffic to your landing page, and increase your ROI on ad spending.

Case study

Abbot

Like most startups, Abbot struggled with marketing and reached out to Kaya for assistance. The team focused on understanding the brand’s vision and product, from which it built the ideal customer profile for targeting.

These strategies allowed Kaya to align the brand, its product, its messaging, and the target audience, leading to marketing gains for Abbot.

Kaya has been helping us out with some marketing as well, and they have been AMAZING to work with. Highly recommend talking to them!

Paul Nakata

Founder/CEO, Abbot

FAQ

Final thoughts

At some point, startup founders find themselves deciding between a startup marketing agency vs. a traditional agency. Traditional agencies are experienced and have broad market reach, but they are usually costly and lack flexibility. They are also over-reliant on standardized approaches.

Such a mode of operation is unsuitable for startups, given the need for a lean, agile, and fast approach. Hence, a startup marketing agency is suitable for early-stage businesses and startups, and Kaya has the proven credentials to help transform your marketing.

Ready for your next phase of growth?

We’re your ready-made growth engine. Save time and money with our world-class team and marketing analytics. See results in as soon as two weeks 🚀